diagnosing glass breakage
And just like in a masonry arch, if you remove the keystone, the arch â or glass in this case â comes tumbling down. Glazing contractors can offset this risk by installing capillary tubes that regulate pressure changes in IGUs. Two types of inclusions are nickel sulfide and aluminum oxide “stones.”. In order to find the direction of entrance and exit, there are 3 steps to complete: Find the radial fractures that connect with the first concentric fracture. This growth caused additional stresses that likely led to the breakage. This type of failure is often a design issue. Now we'll look at four kinds of breakage: Impact breakage of glass pool fences; Tension cracks around glass pool fencing Diagnosing Cracks in Fused Glass One of my least favorite things in the world is opening the kiln and finding a cracked piece of glass! Bellovary holds a Bachelor of Engineering degree in mechanical engineering from Youngstown State University. Similar to water, nickel sulfide increases in volume as it cools. If this is the case then it’s time to look for a new one. It’s often helpful to make a basic diagram (see Figure 1) of the fracture lines. It is crucial to keep children, pets and any spectators well away from the area during the actual act of breaking the glass. This can become problematic later when a glass is in-service and its temperature exposure restarts the phase transformation, triggering the volume growth of nickel sulfide stones and re-instigating conditions that can lead to breakage. Presentation at IIBEC Building Enclosure Symposium, âNightmares on the Edge: Lawsuits About Concrete Slab Tolerance and Deflection Related to Windows and Curtainwallsâ, Houston, TX. If it is located in the strata in the glass between tension and compression, and it grows, kaboom! Impact breakageÂ If you know anything about glass, you know that it can break, and when it breaks, itâs not a good thing. As it increases cost and lead time it is often not taken up by clients who may not be aware of the risks. Although a relatively rare occurrence, glass breaking after being installed in high-rise buildings raises several questions beyond just the immediate need to replace the unit or units. Seeing a cubic breakage pattern does not tell you why the glass broke, it only tells you that the glass was tempered. A nickel sulfide inclusion is a tiny rock of material that remains in the glass. Broken glass injuries can be serious, even deadly. NOTE: Most thermally induced stress breaks in architectural glazing applications occur in the winter, when it is typically colder overnight and the low-angle sun in the morning heats the center of the glass more quickly than the edges. These can usually be found online for under $50. To find the origin of a break, the first step is to assess its direction by inspecting the fracture lines, or ‘Wallner lines,’ in the glass. Fracture Diagnosis of Glass Containers Expert Fracture Diagnosis techniques applied to glass breakage to identify cause, provide solutions and prevent future breakage. Technical Forum: Diagnosing Glass Breakage. However, there can be a near-identical breakage pattern which emanates from damage in the glass edge that fails as normal stresses, such as thermal, are applied. However, this is not a reliable process and some glass may still spontaneously break. Typically initiated by the building owner or glazing contractor, this investigation must start with identifying the origin of the break. It’s no wonder that architects make it the centerpiece of building designs. If you chose to do so, first clean the glass with acetone (nail polish remover). The stress or tension level at which the breakage occurred. Once a crack in glass is identified, the safest option is to replace it immediately. When they detect the frequency or shock waves associated with glass shattering, they sound an alarm. So hereâs a tip for readers who actually do take showers: If your shower door shatters, stand still for a moment and take stock of the situation. A reliable method for estimating the stress level of a break at failure is a mirror radius measurement. Radius dimensions are determined by crack propagation velocity characteristics. Like many brittle materials, glass, which has much higher compressive strength than tensile strength, breaks or fails when stresses approach or exceed the material’s limits. Here’s how this could happen. These adjustment-free and easy-to-install units detect breaking of all standard framed glass types and thickness while ignoring non-framed glass breakage and other possible sources of false alarms. Assuming you don't want to start smashing glasses to test the sensor, your best bet is to get a glass break tester. Reader Joe reported in 2018, adding insulation in the form of solid foam against the interior of a thick plate glass window in an un-heated home might result in a broken window. Diagnosing the cause of fracture can be a difficult job for an installer, but is often necessary to ensure a solution can be found and to prevent a similar break happening again. If the temperature difference across a lite of glass is great enough, the accompanying stresses can reach levels that cause breakage. Larger Rock Less VelocityÂ This vandalâs eyes were bigger than his throwing arm. In this position since 2014, he conducts annual audits of industrial production facilities and provides process improvement suggestions to elite fenestration fabricators within the Vitro Certified™ Fabricator Network. In its pristine state, glass, as a prominent element in architectural design, can define contemporary buildings. Testing Glass Break Sensors & Diagnosing Problems: Glass break sensors can be a bit more difficult to test. Allergen Spillage Solids Kit. Now we'll look at four kinds of breakage: Impact breakage of glass pool fences; Tension cracks around glass pool fencing Figure 3High-Stress Mechanical Tension Break. Enquire Now for Tempered Glass Most of the times, a tempered glass will disintegrate and fall out of the fixing, but the cause of breakage can be assessed with reasonable fairness, if it stays in fixing. One of the scariest, yet somewhat common type of tempered glass spontaneous breakage is in glass shower doors. If you have a glass breakage injuryÂ email meÂ at email@example.com. When the glass is reheated during heat strengthening or full tempering, any existing nickel sulfide stones will shrink to their smaller, high-temperature stable α form. You can well imagine that a little rock embedded in a slab of glass which is under high tension/compression forces, could weaken the glass and eventually cause glass breakage. Thermal stress results from several factors including weather, the method of glass installation, and the insulation around the material. Vitro Glass is not aware of a single confirmed case of spontaneous breakage of heat-strengthened glass due to nickel sulfide stone inclusions. Although architectural glass and fenestration manufacturers continue to develop advanced technologies to make their products as “break-proof” as possible, absolute perfection is simply not possible due to flaws inherent in the glass manufacturing process and the wide range of in-service environments in which glass products must ultimately perform. The slower cooling cycle used to make heat-strengthened glass allows the stones to complete this phase transformation. In reality, the breakage was likely caused by a phase transformation that increased (from 2 percent to 4 percent) the volume of the inclusion. This can be easily done by examining the direction of the Wallner lines on individual pieces of glass. These devices are great additions to home security because they can remain armed all the time, unlike motion detectors, which must be turned off when you or your family are at home. Glass ceiling, meet Kamala Harris: The California senator made history Saturday by becoming the first woman and woman of color elected vice president, NPR reports. Then get the hell out and never shower again. Thermal stress breaks often originate at the edge of the glass and form virtually 90-degree angles to the edge and surface of the glass. Today we will look at four types of glass breakage: Impact breakage; Stress cracks; Edge damage Put another way, when an external force applied to a glass product exceeds its maximum strength, the product will fail. When the breaking stress is low, the mirror radius is often radial and may extend deeply into the substrate. Because of this potential phenomenon, Vitro Glass has a long-standing preference for the specification and use of heat-strengthened glass, except where tempered glass is mandated for safety or other purposes by code. The lack of crystallographic planes in glass can allow certain break patterns to be observed and then associated with modes of failure. If you read the previous post, you will already be down with the fact that glass is made from melted powders. This can be quite disconcerting when, as has happened in a public place which will go unnamed here in our great city, large, thick panes of tempered glass basically blew up fairly frequently. A âstress crackâ will usually only happen in annealed or heat strengthened glass. As an example, a ball on the pool floor along with area children running away usually may be considered symptoms of impact breakage. High-stress breakage due to impact at the glass edge or surfaces near the edge is typically the easiest to identify, as multiple fractures emanate from the point of impact in a spider web fashion (see Figure 9). Glass, and especially tempered glass, sometimes breaks all by itself. 4. Nickel Sulphide (NiS) inclusions are a known issue for toughened glass, resulting from the presence of nickel contaminants in the glass melt reacting with sulphur, but Glass Technology Services urges property owners and insurers not to assume that a NiS inclusion is the cause of an unexplained breakage. Vandal with big ideas hurled a sizable rock and achieved a big glass breakage pattern, but failed to breach the fortress. Reflective blinds and a South exposure combined to create a high frequency of this type of breakage. In this case, the break origin is often located near the edge of the glass. Quite often the perverted glass will explode while the unsuspecting victim is naked and in the shower. In practice the tensile strength of annealed glass is much lower. In this case the edge damage, not the thermal stress is the culprit. There are low-stress and high-stress mechanical tension breaks: In Figure 2, the break origin is not 90 degrees to the edge of the glass, indicating a tension break caused by bending. These rib-shaped marks, distinguished by a wave-like pattern, begin at the break origin and radiate along break branches, and almost always project into the concave face of these lines. A prevalent contributing factor of breakage is edge damage. Even minor defects on the edge of a glass panel can reduce its strength by more than 50 percent, compromising its ability to resist both thermal and mechanical loads. The lack of crystallographic planes in glass will cause this type of crack to proceed perpendicular to the applied tension stress. This is exacerbated at higher temperatures—when the temperature differential exceeds 70 degrees F, as each 20-degree differential increase is equivalent to an altitude increase of 1,000 feet. The root cause of spontaneous breakage of tempered glass has been narrowed down to two potential issues: Cracks in Tempered Glass Causing Spontaneous Breakage Any flaw in the edge or glass surface can cause spontaneous breakage. One of the most common cracks that you see in recycled glass is incompatibility. It’s important to research framing systems and IGU spacers when altitude and temperature changes are factors. Photo of broken glass. Any undesirable material embedded in glass is considered an inclusion. By Timothy Bellovary, Technical Services Engineer, Vitro Architectural Glass. Today we are going to look at a few of the causes of cracks in fused glass, and what we can learn from them. He was probably quite correct, but it's likely that additional factors were involved. With E = 70 GPa, r0= 0,2 nm and = 3 J m 2, we obtain a theoretical strength of 32 GPa for a typical glass . Regardless of the source, responsible glass manufacturers go to great lengths to ensure that inclusions are kept to a minimum. In this case, the building had both: edge damage and underspecified glass. The combination of contact, surface damage and localized gradients can greatly increase the likelihood of breakage. Both Glass break sensors and motion sensors are the great additions to a home, these detectors will only activate an alarm if the door or window is opened. How you handle and repair glass depends on first identifying the type of glass and diagnosing the reason for the breakage. Other sources of impact can be detected during the fabrication process or the transit and installation of the glass; these often appear at the edges. As with mechanical stress, there are two types of thermal stress breaks: low stress and high stress. When the assembly and installation of an IGU occur in two different places, a change in altitude—even as little as 5,000 feet—that changes atmospheric pressure, can jeopardize the unit’s integrity, causing the seal to rapidly fail and potentially leading to breakage. He selected a smaller stone, which he was able to accelerate to a greater velocity, sufficient to completely puncture the glass. These densities factor in to the glass quality ratings by ASTM C1036. The origin of the break can be determined by: Figure 1Diagram of Fracture Line Direction. Identifying the break origin can provide hints about the following: Mode of glass failure—Was it mechanical or thermally induced stress? Figure 6 shows break origins resulting from high tensile stresses, such as bending or thermal stress breaks. They are exposed to banging against bumpers, heat from the shower, wrenching action of through-mounted towel bars and of course, nickel sulfide inclusions. Glass break detectors complement door and window sensors by monitoring sound or vibration. They work efficiently to keep your family safe from the intruders. The impact was large enough, however, to break the interior lite of the insulating glass unit. 3. Other contributing factors—Were there digs (deep, short scratches) resulting from glass-to-glass or glass-to-metal contact? Conducting “post-mortems” on glass breaks helps investigators identify the general reasons for each incident, including the type of failure that caused the break, and the potential original source of the damage. Timothy Bellovary is a technical services engineer at Vitro Architectural Glass (formerly PPG Flat Glass). Diagnosing the cause of glass breakage can be a no-brainer. For instance, when the sun hits the glass and warms up its center, but the edges remain cold, the thermal gradient produces increased stress, potentially leading to breakage. Identifying the break origin can provide hints about the following: To find the origin of a break, the first step is to assess its direction by inspecting the fracture lines, or “Wallner lines,” in the glass. During this process, called annealing, inclusions can undergo a phase transformation (α to β) and become stable, without causing breakage. Studies show that altitude changes of only 1,000 feet accompanied by large temperature differences between the installation and assembly sites can cause IGU failures after extended periods of time. One week after we finished installing windows in a new high school, local kids had a field day with the rocks and our new windows. Although most inclusions do not directly cause breakages, their size, composition and location are the primary factors in the small percentage of inclusion-related incidents that actually occur. For example, a lite of glass might appear to have been broken by high, thermally induced stresses, when, in fact, a more-detailed analysis might reveal that impact damage that reduced the thermal-loading threshold of the glass may have been the actual cause. The combination of size and speed resulted in a localized pattern of glass breakage. Letâs count the problems: 1. The stress or tension level at which the breakage occurred. Below see an artists graphic representation of a nickel sulfide inclusion. In the picture below you can see two sets of impact breakage patterns. Try to grab it and lay it down on the glass so you can walk out. Depending on the severity of the impact, the immediate area surrounding the break origin might be cracked, crushed or missing (see Figure 9). Ten top tips for solving a glass break Contaminates in batch materials and furnace refractory degradation are often contributing factors of inclusions. Today we will look at four types of glass breakage: Typical impact glass breakage without puncture. Figure 2Low-Stress Mechanical Tension Break. The resulting shards between these cracks are dangerous! In some situations, it’s helpful to expand the investigation beyond determining the type of breakage and the stress level of the break. Glass is fragile and subject to breakage. Translating the fracture on the glass panes by using a digitizer tablet which imported the data to a CAD.DWG file. Pull a glass out of the oven or dishwasher when it is hot and place ice water into the glass and it may break due to thermal shock. Although he scored a large area of glass damage, he failed to achieve the goal of full glass penetration. Generally, there are three reasons tempered glass will break: impact, edge damage or inclusions. Artists representation of nickel sulfide inclusion. When glass breaks, the proper handling procedures, generally described in a safety policy, ensure the safe disposal of the material without risk of injury. ViTRON™ uses a unique pattern recognition analysis of framed pane glass breakage, providing superior detection combined with excellent false alarm immunity. Sometimes, however, glass breaks for no obvious reason. Despite its numerous appearance and performance advantages, though, glass has its breaking point. Pinpointing the actual source of the damage can help prevent or reduce future occurrences of breakage. Testing and Fracture Diagnosis of Pharmaceutical Glassware » The objective of this seminar is to teach students appropriate fracture diagnosis techniques that are needed to solve glass breakage and other performance related problems. A This glass is tempered and laminated. If packing into glass containers, have a dedicated colour‐coded hand brush, dustpan, waste bag & printed disposal procedure in a sealed bag For glass‐packaging production, specify what to do if glass breakage occurs on or adjacent to the filler and/or the capper/lidder Tips Breaks caused by thermal stress occur because of large temperature differences, most commonly between the edge and center of the glass. Watch out: while the facts and details of this report are incomplete. In contrast, the rapid cooling cycle used to produce fully tempered glass stops the phase transformation, thereby trapping the stones before they complete their volume growth. Whether it’s a one-off or part of a continuing pattern of incidents, glass breakage is inconvenient, potentially dangerous and costly—for building owners, construction professionals and other stakeholders. If you must remove these shards, remove the upper ones first, then the lower ones. Mirror radii appear in various forms, depending on the stress level of the fracture (see following illustrations). Normally, when tempered glass breaks, it falls down into a pile of little cubes. The relationship of the radius of the mirror surface of the break origin to the stress that caused the breakage, known as “PPG/Orr’s Equation,” is expressed by the following: The graph in Figure 8 also shows the radius-to-stress relationship at various levels of breaking stress. Two common modes are mechanical and thermal. Although these questions are typically part of a more in-depth investigation, any incident always demands an answer to this fundamental question: Why did the glass break? The characteristics of tinted and spandrel glasses (higher heat absorption) and glass that is glazed into large concrete or steel structures (edges stay cooler longer) may contribute to the intensity of thermal-variance stresses in these applications. This is possible only if pieces of the broken glass can be retained or re-assembled into the original orientation. As the focal point of high-visibility structures, expansive glazing areas and large insulating glass units (IGUs) are taking up more space on curtain walls, storefronts and interior building components than ever before. Plus, it’s not the most attractive solution either. m= Er /0. Topics to be covered are: Quantitative and Comparative Fracture Diagnosis … This breakage pattern is a tell-tale sign that either the glass edge or surface was struck by a foreign object with significant force. Sometimes glass just breaks. In some instances, the cause of breakages can be traced to inclusions, which can be non-homogenized, or not fully melted, batch materials or contaminates such as nickel and aluminum. Hopefully you are not cut too badly. The victim must walk barefooted over a field of freshly shattered glass shards. Quality for clear glasses ranges from Q1 (used in the production of high-quality mirrors) to Q6 (applications in which blemishes are not a concern). Heat strengthened glass may have been a better choice for the application. It is a very bad idea to modify glass after it is tempered! After using the above tips to diagnose your dishwasher fault, you may find that it is indeed beyond repair. For the glass bottles, the fracture pattern was likewise documented by hand sketching using an acetate overlay, and the overlay was scanned at 600 dpi. Another potential underlying factor that contributes to breakage is thermal variance, which could be caused by interior and exterior shading. Diagnosing the basis for glass pool fences breakage may be a no brainer. This vandal chose quality over quantity. However, the term âstress crackâ can be misleading.Â If annealed glass is subjected to thermal fluctuations that create glass stress beyond its capabilities, the glass will break in a way that will relieve the stresses induced by thermal changes. We were not able to obtain a photo of the 1/4" plate glass window break described by Joe, below. Following policy using the proper equipment aids in the safety of all involved with broken glass. By using the techniques outlined in this article, building owners, contractors, engineers, glass manufacturers and other stakeholders may be able to accurately identify the likely origin of such failures and also potentially use that information to prevent future occurrences. These rib-shaped marks, distinguished by a wave-like pattern through the thickness of the glass, begin at the break origin and radiate along break branches. This is particularly true if the nucleation point of the crack was caused by a damaged edge or an inclusion. As an example, a ball on the pool floor along with area children running away usually may be considered symptoms of impact breakage. The relation of the failure stress and size of origin is explained with Eq. If an object has sufficient energy to propagate a crack through the thickness of the glass, then a “spider web” pattern will form. Look at the ridges formed by the object. Glass can break for a number of reasons, from edge damage to poor installation or thermal stress. Although edge damage in and of itself doesn’t break the glass—after all, the glass may remain functional throughout its service life—it creates a weak point that may make the glass susceptible to conditions that increase the likelihood of breakage. Glass shards from broken annealed or heat strengthened glass are dangerous and must be handled with care. The objective of this seminar is to teach students appropriate fracture diagnosis techniques that are needed to solve glass breakage and other performance related problems. The tubes must be properly terminated at the final location by crimping or sealing to prevent moisture ingression. Inclusions are tiny impurities in the glass. Use heavy rubber gloves, protect your arms, head, eyes and feet, and place the shards in a cardboard box, not a garbage bag. There are sharp cubes of glass projectiles flying around. Did a projectile hit the glass? Most of the time spontaneous glass breakage is the result of improper annealing of the glass by the manufacturer or thermal shock of the glass during normal usage. Breakage due to thermal stress is most common in large pieces of sealed insulating glass with heavy heat-absorbing (reflective) coatings. Glass break sensor also works differently depending on the type of glass. Back to the ball-through-the-window example, the glass breakage pattern will vary depending on the speed and mass of the ball, and the size, thickness and post-annealing treatments that were performed on the glass prior to the ballgame. If you look closely, you can see the crack origin on this tempered glass. A more well-known, but also quite rare cause of spontaneous glass breakage is nickel sulfide inclusions. Only the most patient glass consultants with the most generous client would ever consider piecing the cubes together to determine the cause of breakage. To identify what damaged the glass in the first place, four factors are examined during this analysis: Identifying the nature of the breakage pattern can determine whether a foreign object hit the glass and whether the impact was perpendicular or parallel. Find out which part of the glass faced where (what part faced in and what faced out) Then look at the broken edge. The Glass and Glazing Federation (GGF) will shortly publish data sheet 4.4.2 titled Thermally Treated Soda Lime Silicate Glass Products – Spontaneous Breakage, which FIS members helped to review. Today we will look at four types of glass breakage: Impact breakage; Stress cracks; Edge damage; Spontaneous breakage View details. Was the glass properly installed? Many inclusions “behave” the same way glass does: They expand in heat and contract in cold. Investigation of spontaneous breakage of ballistic glass in TV studio, Washington, DC. Care should be taken if the IGU includes an MSVD low-e coating because any moisture ingress during transportation and storage when the tube is open can be detrimental to the low-e coating. Sometimes it’s easy to know why glass breaks. For example, a ball on the floor combined with neighborhood kids running away generally can be considered symptoms of impact-related glass breakage. Identifying the root cause of failure requires the practice of fracture diagnosis, a highly developed science that consists of the examination. A very well-hit hardball, or a well thrown rock squarely hitting a piece of annealed glass will produce glass breakage with a circular puncture with cracks emanating outward from the point of impact. In hotels, multiply the risk factors by the number of rooms and the lack of care typically taken by a hotel patron. * Superglue has the potential to help the situation, but it won’t be a long-term fix. Drawing arrows (indicating fracture line direction) pointing into the concave face of break wave markings in the glass edge. As mentioned previously, edge damage can reduce the strength of the glass by more than 50 percent, which increases the likelihood of breakage due to mechanical and/or thermal stress. The PVB (polyvinyl butyral) interlayer held the pieces in place, giving us an opportunity to observe that impact related glass breakage can be visible, even in tempered glass. The presence of a nickel sulfide inclusion in the center residual tension stress region of thermally tempered glass can lead an investigator to believe that the breakage occurred spontaneously. Breakages due to impact or wind loading are less likely to stay in frame. Danger of broken glass injury. In this example, a smooth fracture face forms across the thickness of the substrate. A crack propagates itself through glass with increasing velocity as it moves further from the point of origin. Figure 7Low-Stress Mirror Radii(R = Mirror radii). Broken glass in tub after shower door shattered. Blunt impact on long lite of annealed glass. 1 , Glass breakage procedure x1; Video. You may also be interested in: Allergen Spillage Powder Kit. When there is a pattern of repeated glass breaks, it’s critical to explore the reasons for such incidents. The objective of this seminar is to teach students the appropriate fracture diagnosis techniques that are required to solve complex glass breakage and other performance related problems. Carefully selected cleaning kit designed specifically for dealing with allergen spills involving powders. The most common contributing factor of breakage, mechanical stress, occurs when forces resulting from bending or impact exceed the Modulus of Rupture (MOR), a critical metric in stress analysis.